MagicStatslast updated 2026-11-16, up to date

DataSet

CNSConspiracy

draft innovationreleased 2014-06-06primary set

Set details

BoosterPack EVPacks / boxBox EVBox marketLow askEV / marketPricedFor saleSupply wkMkt supply wkDryingAs of
DraftTCGplayer$7.3836$265.76$257.66—1.03×99.8%13 / 89.5 wk——2026-11-16

Sealed price

Inventory

boxes sold per week · last 52 weeks

Ask depth

lowest ask $266.99 · 8 listings · 14 units · snapshot 2026-11-16

Units for sale at or below each ask (price + shipping ÷ qty), Conspiracy Booster Box. Asks above 2× the lowest ask are left off.

Card price drop-off

Per box: market price (sheet finish) of every card it can open, by rank, cards ≥ $1.00 · 2026-11-15

Commentary

Statements from @AlphaInvestments69 videos, extracted from transcripts; each links to the moment it was said

Play 25

  1. 2025-09-11bullishSpeaker is bullish on Conspiracy, judging it way too cheap for its price, and buys it from collections and stores.“I'm pretty bullish on sets like Conspiracy and Battle Bond from that era”▶ 3:09
  2. 2024-12-24bullishConspiracy boxes were mispriced; speaker says they will not return to around $139.“like conspiracy 1 conspiracy 2 isn't going back to like 139”▶ 26:10
  3. 2022-11-09bullishHas no concerns about holding older sets like Conspiracy.“I have no concerns on uh conspiracy one”▶ 11:26
  4. 2022-01-19neutralOriginal Conspiracy boxes are less valuable than Conspiracy: Take the Crown boxes.“conspiracy two is worth more money and people like it more than the older counterpart”▶ 7:19
  5. 2021-06-05bullishConspiracy boxes sold to patrons for about $69.99 seven years ago and have climbed to roughly $200-300 per box.“the product climbed from like 80 bucks in price to how high it is today was it two 300 a box”▶ 13:08
  6. 2021-04-06neutralOpened Conspiracy box has expected value pushing up to almost $250 a box, with lots of value in the uncommon slot.“the expected value is pushing up to almost 250 dollars a box”▶ 1:01
  7. 2021-04-06neutralAfter Wizards said Conspiracy would be printed to oblivion, the market panicked and singles were dumped very low, but the set aged well.“the market panicked and everybody just dumped singles so low”▶ 4:35
  8. 2021-04-06bullishHard to lose money on Conspiracy boxes, which is why prices keep going up.“it's so difficult to lose money on this thing that's why the boxes keep going up”▶ 5:07
  9. 2021-04-06bullishConspiracy 1, Conspiracy 2 and Battlebond boxes will all eventually be $500 boxes.“conspiracy one conspiracy two battle bomb they're all 500 boxes”▶ 11:53
  10. 2019-09-18neutralConspiracy 1 is worth less than Conspiracy 2.“conspiracy one is actually worth less than conspiracy - so”▶ 10:29
  11. 2019-09-12bullishSpeaker expects money to flow into specialty products like conspiracies and Battlebond.“conspiracies and battle bonds and of course even the newer standard sets”▶ 10:19
  12. 2019-08-07neutralConspiracy averages about $160 with no upward movement.“conspiracy one still kind of funny the older one is 160”▶ 6:45
  13. 2019-08-07bearishSpeaker expects flat consolidation and possibly a 10% retracement over twelve months for Conspiracy.“maybe even a negative 10 percent retracement over the next twelve months”▶ 7:46
  14. 2019-07-23bearishConspiracy tanked in value within 90 days of release because of print run.“battle bond conspiracy sets they all tanked in value upon release in 90 days”▶ 9:51
  15. 2019-07-23neutralPrevious supplemental sets like Conspiracy sold from Wizards to distributors at about $60-something, retail around $75-80.“conspiracy or battle bond and your wizard probably sell to distributors for like 60 something dollars”▶ 4:40
  16. 2019-05-23neutralIn 2014 a distributor offered Conspiracy boxes at $73, discounted to $68 for 120+ boxes.“you buy over a hundred and twenty boxes will discount you from seventy three a box to sixty eight a box”▶ 2:06
  17. 2019-05-23bullishConspiracy aged fine despite the print-to-demand label.“conspiracy one and age just fun conspiracy to aged even better battle”▶ 5:45
  18. 2019-05-18neutralEarly Conspiracy box openings were made when nobody wanted the set and everybody bashed it; its prices later skyrocketed.“way at the beginning when nobody wanted conspiracy and everybody bashed it”▶ 13:40
  19. 2019-05-13bullishSold Conspiracy boxes to patrons for about $70 each; cites them as a hold that went up in value after critics stopped talking.“once it goes up in value nobody wants to bring it up anymore”▶ 12:10
  20. 2019-05-11bearishOriginal Conspiracy is underperforming Conspiracy: Take the Crown, which is unusual for out-of-print product.“you have the older one that's like not doing as well as the newer one and that's very unusual”▶ 0:00
  21. 2019-04-28neutralOriginal Conspiracy boxes continue to lag behind Conspiracy 2.“conspiracy one continues to lag”▶ 3:11
  22. 2019-03-16bearishConspiracy got flooded in the market and prices sank like a brick, a mistake Modern Horizons should avoid.“we're not gonna see something like conspiracy to where it just got flooded in the market”▶ 1:04
  23. 2019-03-15neutralConspiracy boxes jumped from $120-130 to $160-170 on eBay; ChannelFireball then unloaded stock in blocks of 20-40 at about $140.“cons had a big move from the 120-130 now it's about 160 to 170 for cons”▶ 5:43
  24. 2019-02-06neutralConspiracy 1 boxes are now cheaper than Conspiracy 2 boxes on eBay.“conspiracy one boxes are now cheaper than conspiracy two boxes”▶ 1:02
  25. 2019-01-19neutralOriginal Conspiracy box expected value is about $130 and foil prices are very high.“I think conspiracy 1's like 130 expected value”▶ 6:49

Collector 0

None.

Other 5

  1. 2026-08-07neutralSpeaker expected Conspiracy to be a $2,000 box but it is nowhere near because nobody cares and it has no power level.“I thought Conspiracy was going to be like a two-thousand-dollar box, no joke.”▶ 14:28
  2. 2021-06-05neutralFoil mythics in Conspiracy were worth $50 up to several hundred dollars thanks to high foil multipliers in this supplemental set.“these foil mythics back in the day were between like fifty dollars and some of the foil mythics were one two three four five hundred dollars”▶ 3:12
  3. 2020-04-05neutralConspiracy mythic Scourge of the Throne foil skyrocketed over $100 a long time ago; unsure if still worth that.“the foil skyrocketed over 100 dollars a long time ago”▶ 14:35
  4. 2019-11-18bullishConspiracy 1 and 2 foils and premiums aged very well in long-term value compared to foils of standard sets that get reprinted more.“a lot of the conspirators the Somerset's conspiracy 1 & 2 particularly the foils and the premiums and the value long term actually aged very well”▶ 3:35
  5. 2019-05-11neutralThe two most expensive cards in original Conspiracy are rares, not mythics, so they are fairly likely to be pulled.“the two most expensive cars in the set are rares not even mythix”▶ 12:05

Market events

Detected nightly over the last 90 days: floor moves, supply changes, sales spikes, price moves, EV crossings, reprints, stance flips, release marks · asks = price + shipping ÷ qty
Details
2026-11-161 event
FloorCNSConspiracy Booster Box-24.5%since 2026-11-13$266.99MuGu Games listed 1 × $266.99 (new); 1 units within 5% of the floor · market $257.66
2026-11-141 event
SupplyCNSConspiracy Booster Box+333.3% unitssince 2026-10-1213 unitsUnits for sale 3 → 13 (+333.3%) · Listings 3 → 7 · floor $353.75 → $353.75 · market $257.66
2026-11-131 event
FloorCNSConspiracy Booster Box-5.4%since 2026-11-09$353.75PhaesicGames repriced 4 × $353.75 from $373.75; 8 units within 5% of the floor · market $257.66
2026-11-091 event
FloorCNSConspiracy Booster Box-2.4%since 2026-11-04$373.75PhaesicGames listed 4 × $373.75 (new); 7 units within 5% of the floor · market $257.66
2026-11-071 event
ATHCNSConspiracy Booster Box+1.9%prev high 2026-11-05$257.66Previous high $252.78 on 2026-11-05
2026-11-041 event
FloorCNSConspiracy Booster Box-2.0%since 2026-10-22$382.98MKE Card listed 1 × $382.98 (new); 4 units within 5% of the floor · market $252.78
2026-10-221 event
FloorCNSConspiracy Booster Box-4.9%since 2026-10-20$390.99Justin CaseMTG listed 1 × $390.99 (new); 1 units within 5% of the floor · market $252.78
2026-10-201 event
FloorCNSConspiracy Booster Box+30.5%vs 2026-10-19$410.993 units within 5% of the floor · market $252.78
2026-10-191 event
FloorCNSConspiracy Booster Box-23.4%since 2026-10-12$314.99Direwolflair listed 1 × $314.99 (new); 1 units within 5% of the floor · market $252.78
2026-10-091 event
ATHCNSConspiracy Booster Box+0.1%prev high 2026-10-08$252.78Previous high $252.54 on 2026-10-08

Events

Reprints, print-run statements and restocks on record (data/supply_events.csv); TBD = reported in commentary, not yet confirmed by a primary source

No events on record. Nothing sourced for this set yet.

Chase cards

10 most valuable printings by latest TCGplayer market (last 14 days) · listings and copies sold in 30 days from the TCGplayer snapshot
  1. 1
    Treasonous Ogre
    #36 · foil · uncommon
    23listed1sold 30d
    $120.532026-11-15
  2. 2
    Misdirection
    #102 · foil · rare
    26listed9sold 30d
    $87.712026-11-15
  3. 3
    Pernicious Deed
    #191 · foil · mythic
    21listed0sold 30d
    $68.412026-11-15
  4. 4
    Phage the Untouchable
    #120 · foil · mythic
    22listed1sold 30d
    $66.222026-11-15
  5. 5
    Exploration
    #164 · foil · rare
    19listed2sold 30d
    $62.642026-11-15
  6. 6
    Hydra Omnivore
    #169 · foil · mythic
    9listed1sold 30d
    $49.752026-11-15
  7. 7
    Dack Fayden
    #42 · foil · mythic
    33listed1sold 30d
    $49.482026-11-15
  8. 8
    Silent Arbiter
    #204 · foil · rare
    23listed3sold 30d
    $46.932026-11-15
  9. 9
    Marchesa, the Black Rose
    #49 · foil · mythic
    28listed0sold 30d
    $38.172026-11-15
  10. 10
    Basandra, Battle Seraph
    #184 · foil · rare
    16listed8sold 30d
    $36.272026-11-15