MagicStatslast updated 2026-11-16, up to date

DataSet

C18Commander 2018

commanderreleased 2018-08-10primary set

Set details

DeckPack EVPacks / boxDeck EVDeck marketLow askEV / marketPricedFor saleSupply wkMkt supply wkDryingAs of
Adaptive EnchantmentTCGplayer——$47.56$61.763 / $67.770.77×100.0%70 / 1443.1 wk3.7 wk~drying2026-11-16
Exquisite InventionTCGplayer——$46.03$50.482 / $58.450.91×100.0%26 / 1469.3 wk0.0 wk—2026-11-16
Nature's VengeanceTCGplayer——$35.86$70.643 / $75.580.51×100.0%24 / 1564.0 wk26.7 wk~drying2026-11-16
Subjective RealityTCGplayer——$50.41$64.102 / $68.940.79×100.0%32 / 1217.1 wk2.7 wk~1 of 22026-11-16

Sealed price

Inventory

boxes sold per week · last 52 weeks

Ask depth

lowest ask $67.77 · 14 listings · 69 units · snapshot 2026-11-16

Units for sale at or below each ask (price + shipping ÷ qty), Commander 2018 Commander Deck Adaptive Enchantment. Asks above 2× the lowest ask are left off.

Card price drop-off

Per box: market price (sheet finish) of every card it can open, by rank, cards ≥ $1.00 · 2026-11-15

Commentary

Statements from @AlphaInvestments69 videos, extracted from transcripts; each links to the moment it was said

Play 2

  1. 2019-05-15neutralCommander 2018 is the example of a set seen as garbage that tanked then rebounded as it aged.“is gonna be a commander 2018 where everybody thinks it's garbage and it tanks”▶ 2:08
  2. 2019-04-28bullishCommander 2018 jumped 10% to $130 as the last big distributor sold out; expects $130-150, leveling off at $150-200.“now I actually think we're gonna start seeing 130-140 all the way up to 150”▶ 8:59

Collector 0

None.

Other 70

  1. 2023-07-12bullishOlder Commander precons dumped on Amazon doubled in value within six months to two years.“if you had bought any of them Commander 2018 1920 you'd have done really well but you would have doubled your money”▶ 20:09
  2. 2023-04-23bullishEven the 2018-2019 Commander decks speaker was ridiculed for have all done well.“even the garbage 2018-2019 Commander said that Rudy was ridiculed for they've all done well”▶ 11:24
  3. 2023-04-16neutralCommander 2018-2020 are the realistic benchmark because Wizards ramped up print runs and did huge second waves while the market was negative.“that's when they ramped up the print runs they did huge second waves”▶ 13:56
  4. 2023-04-15bullishSpeaker told viewers Commander 2018 decks were severely underpriced at about $89 and hoarded eight pallets; it turned out well.“I said Commander 2018 decks were severely underpriced and I thought there was a great long-term potential”▶ 7:14
  5. 2022-12-28bullishCommander 2018 was $89-99 when the speaker pushed it; he now sells it on eBay for $250.“and now I sell Commander 2018 on eBay for 250”▶ 24:00
  6. 2022-01-02neutralCommander 2018 sells for $250-300 a set.“i saw commander 2018 is 250 to 300 a set”▶ 8:15
  7. 2021-11-09neutralCommander 2018 sold really badly originally, yet today those old Commander products are expensive and rare.“commander 2015 sold bad commander 2018 sold really bad”▶ 5:08
  8. 2021-11-02neutralCommander 2018 sold really badly when new, though its cards are now expensive.“commander 2018 sold really bad and i know now everyone's like whoa those are expensive”▶ 5:08
  9. 2021-07-01bullishSpeaker bought Commander 2018 sets around $90, reasoning EV from cracking singles exceeded price so downside was limited.“how much are they like 90 bucks a set there's what's the downside of a commander thing the ev is higher than that”▶ 21:12
  10. 2021-05-05bullishCommander 2018 is now over $200 a set, a huge home run.“commander 2018 is now over 200 a set huge home run”▶ 14:36
  11. 2021-03-19neutralCommander 2018 took two years to move, from about $90 to $200.“commander 20 took two years to actually make its move”▶ 5:14
  12. 2021-01-09neutralIn Nov 2018 Commander 2018 sold on the secondary market between $110 and $130 apiece.“bouncing around between 110 dollars apiece to 130 dollars apiece”▶ 3:48
  13. 2021-01-09neutralCommander 2018's four decks total roughly $150 in singles expected value, about $130 after fees, versus sealed at $110-130.“sealed on the market is currently 110 to 130”▶ 4:52
  14. 2021-01-09bullishMaintains Commander 2018 will go up in value and is not that bad a product, despite widespread ridicule.“i said it's still going to go up in value and it's not that bad of a product”▶ 8:27
  15. 2021-01-02bullishCommander 2018 is at about $180 plus tax and predicted to move toward $200-250 within 90 days.“we're probably going to go to that two 250 and start getting some really big price swings on the 2018 commander”▶ 8:23
  16. 2021-01-02bullishCommander 2018 listed quantity is the lowest in 18 months of tracking, 18 months after going out of print.“the quantity for sale on commander 2018 is incredibly low it's the lowest i've seen since i've been tracking it for the last 18 months”▶ 8:54
  17. 2020-10-18bullishCommander 2018 continues to push really high despite being overprinted.“commander 2018 is continuing to push really high”▶ 16:38
  18. 2020-09-26bullishCommander 2018 has skyrocketed in price since he called it garbage two years ago.“commander 2019 is up ticked a little but nothing dramatic but 2018 is skyrocketed”▶ 16:04
  19. 2020-07-16neutralCommander 2018 is already in the $180s at the time of filming, and Commander 2019 is the better product.“I think commander 2018 that one eighties now”▶ 24:03
  20. 2020-07-09bullishCommander 2018 pushing $160-180; anything under $170-180 out the door is a good price and supply is disturbingly low.“anything below about 170 180 with tax and shipping out the door is considered a good price”▶ 8:16
  21. 2020-07-09bullishCommander 2018 supply looks like Commander 2017 and could go to $200-300.“suckers gonna go two to three hundred ollars”▶ 8:46
  22. 2020-06-30bullishCommander 2018 rose about 80% in 90 days from $100 to around $160 plus tax after a year and a half of flat prices.“almost had about an eighty percent price increase on commander 2018”▶ 4:44
  23. 2020-06-17neutralCommander 2018 is above $160 before tax online, almost $180 out the door.“We're now seeing pushing above $160 before taxes online”▶ 8:15
  24. 2020-06-17neutralSpeaker cut his Commander 2018 position from about 900 sets to 400-450 as price rose.“I reduced it by 50%”▶ 9:17
  25. 2020-05-21bullishCommander 2018 now sells about $160 on eBay, up roughly 50% in 18 months.“they're selling for about 160 dollars a pop”▶ 12:32
  26. 2020-04-23bullishHe bought Commander 2018 at 90-100 and expects 150-200 over a few years, not the 300-400 of Commander 2017.“my perspective would be that over the next few years they would get to 150 to 200 maybe to 20 to 30 range”▶ 6:40
  27. 2020-03-26bullishCommander 2018 fell to $100 after poor reception but has reinflated to about $160-170 with fees as sealed supply drops.“now the price is pushing now to about 160 170 with taxes and fees”▶ 38:04
  28. 2020-03-12bullishCommander 2018 displays average $150-160, up from $100 last year; he calls $150 a bargain and expects $200+.“it is at a hundred and fifty bucks apiece it is still a bargain it will be $200 plus”▶ 8:54
  29. 2020-02-04bullishSpeaker still holds hundreds and hundreds of Commander 2018 sets despite ridicule, betting on long-term change.“I still have you know hundreds and hundreds of commander 2018 sets”▶ 7:42
  30. 2019-12-25neutralC18 rose only from about $120-130 to $140-150 in a year, roughly 10%, a weak performer.“maybe 140 145 150 and where you go so I mean it hasn't moved a lot maybe ten percent”▶ 15:04
  31. 2019-12-04neutralCommander 2018 is the weakest Commander product ever, rated 4-5 out of 10, yet the speaker held it anyway.“It is the weakest commander product they've ever done.”▶ 10:58
  32. 2019-12-04bullishCommander 2018 four-pack price rose in one year from about $105-110 to the $140s on eBay, faster than the speaker expected.“The cheapest price on eBay went from like 105 to 108 to the 140s.”▶ 12:32
  33. 2019-11-27bullishCommander 2018 averages $140-150 now after about 10-15% yearly gains; speaker projects about $200 in two more years.“you're probably gonna get a $200 a piece for a set in two more years”▶ 19:39
  34. 2019-11-14bullishCommander 2018 sells at $140-150, up about 20% in under a year, which he cites as proof his long-term buy call on sealed product works.“150 already at like 20% in less than a year just like commander 2018”▶ 10:28
  35. 2019-09-21bullishCommander 2018 is appreciating faster than predicted, heading to $150-170 by New Year versus the $135-140 target.“it looks like commander 2018 is gonna be pushing 150 to 170”▶ 3:09
  36. 2019-09-12neutralA large reprint like Commander 2018 lets speaker sell decks to patrons cheaply.“if the Reaper is large like commander 2018”▶ 7:46
  37. 2019-09-09bullishCommander 2018 is rising in price faster than speaker expected.“now it's actually going up faster than I thought it would”▶ 5:15
  38. 2019-08-20neutralCommander 2018 sealed decks jumped from about $110-120 to over $150 with no change in single card values.“out of nowhere went from the 110 to 120 range all the way to 150”▶ 0:43
  39. 2019-08-20bullishDistributors have already unloaded nearly all Commander 2018 stock, so supply is shut off while the product ages.“distributors already unloaded pretty much all of the 2018”▶ 3:47
  40. 2019-08-20bullishSpeaker says $150 is the new normal for Commander 2018 sealed, though he doubts it reaches $200.“the 150s is the new normal now for commander 2018”▶ 5:52
  41. 2019-08-20neutralCommander 2018 will not reach the $400 sealed price of Commander 2016 or 2017 because the product is simply not that good.“I don't think commander 2018 is gonna be a $400 product”▶ 9:33
  42. 2019-08-20bullishSpeaker is holding his Commander 2018 inventory and has no intention of selling soon.“selling anymore coming out of 2018 anytime soon”▶ 11:06
  43. 2019-08-12neutralCommander 2018, deemed a terrible product, has recovered to about $140.“commander 2018 was also deemed as a terrible product and guess what it's back to like the one 40s”▶ 1:33
  44. 2019-08-10bullishCommander 2018 went out of print and rose to $300-400 per set after being called a bust; speaker held 500-1000 units.“it goes out of print like come you know 20 18 did and it goes to three four hundred dollars for the set”▶ 12:24
  45. 2019-08-07bullishCommander 2018 averages about $140 ($139.99) on the open market, higher and faster than the expected $120s.“commander 2018 is actually averaging about 140 now”▶ 1:02
  46. 2019-08-07bullishCommander 2018 supply on eBay and TCGplayer has thinned significantly as stores broke decks into singles and distributors sold out.“a significant significant thinning of a supply side of the number of units for sale on eBay and TCG player for commander 2018”▶ 1:33
  47. 2019-08-01bullishCommander 2018 is up about 10% in six months, averaging $135-140 on eBay versus $120.“averaging about 135 to 140 on ebay versus the 120 so we're up about 10”▶ 4:06
  48. 2019-07-20neutralCommander 2018 was considered weak but still sold very well and was successful.“it was still overall very successful product and it sold very well”▶ 12:55
  49. 2019-07-18bullishBought 47 more Commander 2018 displays; sees great long-term potential despite it being the weaker commander product.“I feel it has great long-term potential”▶ 2:02
  50. 2019-07-18neutralCommander 2018 display sat at $110-120 for 6-9 months, now breaking to $130-140.“it's been stuck about 110 to 120 per display on the open market for what six nine months and finally we're breaking to the 130 140”▶ 2:02
  51. 2019-07-18bullishExpects Commander 2018 display near $200 at peak, about 10% yearly appreciation: ~$160s next year, $180-190s in two years.“I do feel this is still going to be a 200-dollar display for the 2018 pack”▶ 2:36
  52. 2019-07-02bullishCommander 2018 displays are now 130-140 and he expects 150-200 per sealed display by end of year.“I do expect them to go to 150 $200 per sealed display probably with by the end of the year”▶ 7:20
  53. 2019-05-31bullishCommander 2018 decks stuck at $120-130 are breaking through, with single card prices finally appreciating; speaker holds ~550 of 1,000.“the 120 130 which commander 2018 has been stuck at is actually breaking through finally we're having some appreciation on the single card prices”▶ 3:45
  54. 2019-05-31bullishCommander 2018 sold on eBay at $130 with little supply below $144; it could be the next leg up.“it does appear that command of 2018 could be the next leg up”▶ 4:16
  55. 2019-05-31bullishSpeaker expects Commander 2018 to rise only about 5% by year end, roughly $135 to $145; a slow long-term play.“I think you'll see some small slow maybe another 5% from now the end of the year”▶ 4:48
  56. 2019-04-17bullishThe four Commander 2018 decks combined rose from about $145 to almost $200 on TCG mid in 45 days, a slow quiet uptick.“it went from about 145 for all four decks combined now we're pushing almost $200”▶ 1:38
  57. 2019-04-17bullishMost distributors are out of Commander 2018; only two still have stock, roughly 300-500 and 100-200 units.“most of the Distributors are out of Commander 2018”▶ 2:08
  58. 2019-04-17bullishKept about 300 Commander 2018 units after selling to patrons because he believes in the product.“I still kept about 300 of the units okay because I believe in it”▶ 2:40
  59. 2019-04-17bullishCommander 2018 bottomed in January 2019 at about $197 per set and has since moved up to around $230.“Commander 2018 bottomed out for like 197 a piece in 20 in January”▶ 3:43
  60. 2019-04-17neutralSealed Commander 2018 price has not moved yet, averaging about $120-130 online, with some retail stores near $150.“the sealed product price still averages about 120 to 130”▶ 5:16
  61. 2019-04-17bullishExpects Commander 2018 supply to dry up in the next three to six months once the new Commander product releases, with real price moves.“in the next three to six months is going to start really drying up”▶ 6:20
  62. 2019-03-19neutralCommander 2018 was liked for its new cards but lacked additional reprint equity.“Commander 2018 was good the only thing that was missing was just additional reprint Equity”▶ 7:20
  63. 2019-03-18bullishCommander 2018 will follow the same path as the Challenger Decks and become a steal after 12-24 months.“I think it's gonna be the same thing with commander 2018”▶ 6:20
  64. 2019-03-15neutralCommander 2018 had traded around $110-120 on eBay, bottomed near $105, and is now $123-134 after an odd supply movement.“now we're back between 123 and 134 commander 2018 strange uptake there”▶ 1:34
  65. 2019-03-02neutralCommander 2018 was admitted by Wizards to have had too little reprint equity versus prior Commander products.“Commander 2018 Gavin did even come out publicly and said they were too weak”▶ 6:47
  66. 2019-02-24bullishCommander 2018 is weaker than 2016/2017 but still rises in value more slowly; at $120 each, speaker prefers two over one Mythic Edition.“it's still going to go up in value but it'll be a slower trajectory upwards”▶ 8:19
  67. 2019-02-14bullishCommander 2018 singles have spiked, such as Black Demon rising from $1 to $12.“you have a black demon that's gone from a dollar to twelve”▶ 2:52
  68. 2019-02-14neutralCommander 2018 decks carry an expected value of about $150, or $120-130 after trimming low-end cards, higher than the speaker expected.“the expected value of the whole Ford x-series maintains probably around $150”▶ 2:52
  69. 2019-02-14neutralDistributors sell Commander 2018 for about $93-94 a unit; speaker offers it to long-term patrons at $79 shipped.“distributors are about ninety three ninety four dollars a unit”▶ 4:26
  70. 2019-01-15bearishCommander 2018 is weaker than Commander 2017 with cheaper cards on paper.“commander 2018 was weaker than Commander 2017”▶ 5:10

Market events

Detected nightly over the last 90 days: floor moves, supply changes, sales spikes, price moves, EV crossings, reprints, stance flips, release marks · asks = price + shipping ÷ qty
Details
2026-11-131 event
FloorC18Adaptive Enchantment+5.5%since 2026-10-27$66.956 units within 5% of the floor · market $62.12
2026-11-091 event
PriceC18Exquisite Invention+5.7%since 2026-10-09$49.89vs 2026-10-09 · tcgcsv
2026-11-081 event
FloorC18Subjective Reality-6.1%since 2026-10-31$68.95NiliaCards listed 2 × $68.95 (new); 3 units within 5% of the floor · market $63.70
2026-10-311 event
FloorC18Subjective Reality+6.5%vs 2026-10-30$73.452 × $68.95 (NiliaCards) withdrawn; 11 units within 5% of the floor · market $63.01
2026-10-301 event
FloorC18Subjective Reality+3.8%since 2026-10-19$68.952 units within 5% of the floor · market $63.01
2026-10-291 event
EV ratioC18Exquisite Invention1.00× → 0.98×EV $47.78Deck EV $47.78 vs market $48.77
2026-10-271 event
FloorC18Adaptive Enchantment-5.1%since 2026-10-19$63.45Untapped Games listed 2 × $63.45 (new); 2 units within 5% of the floor · market $62.79

Events

Reprints, print-run statements and restocks on record (data/supply_events.csv); TBD = reported in commentary, not yet confirmed by a primary source

No events on record. Nothing sourced for this set yet.

Chase cards

10 most valuable printings by latest TCGplayer market (last 14 days) · listings and copies sold in 30 days from the TCGplayer snapshot
  1. 1
    Aminatou, the Fateshifter
    #37 · foil · mythic
    63listed107sold 30d
    $19.012026-11-15
  2. 2
    Unwinding Clock
    #228 · nonfoil · rare
    103listed90sold 30d
    $18.242026-11-15
  3. 3
    Lord Windgrace
    #43 · foil · mythic
    248listed59sold 30d
    $15.572026-11-15
  4. 4
    Bear Umbra
    #131 · nonfoil · rare
    99listed58sold 30d
    $12.982026-11-15
  5. 5
    Silent-Blade Oni
    #191 · nonfoil · rare
    251listed48sold 30d
    $5.292026-11-15
  6. 6
    Fury Storm
    #22 · nonfoil · rare
    257listed61sold 30d
    $4.722026-11-15
  7. 7
    Myth Unbound
    #32 · nonfoil · rare
    157listed71sold 30d
    $4.572026-11-15
  8. 8
    Sower of Discord
    #19 · nonfoil · rare
    200listed39sold 30d
    $4.272026-11-15
  9. 9
    Varina, Lich Queen
    #48 · foil · mythic
    224listed73sold 30d
    $4.252026-11-15
  10. 10
    Tuvasa the Sunlit
    #47 · foil · mythic
    232listed41sold 30d
    $3.982026-11-15